Law & Governance | August 2026 | 4 min read
| President Zardari rejects FBR’s challenge, keeping an FTO order for taxpayer access to assessment records in force. |
Quick Takeaways
- President Asif Ali Zardari has rejected FBR’s representation against an FTO order.
- The case concerns access to notices, order sheets and tax assessment records for Tax Year 2020.
- The FTO had held that the taxpayer could obtain the records under law and Article 19-A.
- Tax authorities were directed to provide the requested documents within 15 days.
- The decision reinforces transparency and taxpayer defence rights in assessment proceedings.
President Asif Ali Zardari’s rejection of the FBR representation has kept an important transparency order alive for taxpayers who need access to their own case records.
| Tax Year 2020 | 15 Days | Article 19-A |
| Records requested by taxpayer | FTO timeline for document supply | Right to information cited |
President Maintains FTO Order Against FBR
President Asif Ali Zardari has rejected a representation filed by the Federal Board of Revenue against an order of the Federal Tax Ombudsman. The decision upholds the taxpayer’s right to obtain records linked with tax assessment proceedings and leaves the FTO’s original direction in place.
The matter involved a non-resident taxpayer who had complained against the Tax Office, Islamabad. The complaint said the office had withheld copies of notices, order sheets and other assessment documents related to Tax Year 2020. These records were needed so the taxpayer could understand the proceedings and respond properly.
| Legal Context: The ruling is important because access to case records is not a technical luxury for taxpayers. It is a basic part of preparing a lawful and effective defence. |
Why the Taxpayer Sought Assessment Records
In its February 19, 2026 order, the Federal Tax Ombudsman held that the taxpayer had a right under the law, read with Article 19-A of the Constitution, to obtain copies of the relevant record. Article 19-A deals with access to information, subject to legal regulation and reasonable restrictions.
The FTO directed the tax authorities to provide the requested documents within 15 days. The order covered the record connected with the assessment proceedings, including notices and order sheets. In simple terms, the taxpayer asked for the documents that showed what action had been taken, when notices were issued and how the case had moved inside the tax office.
| Stage | Action | Record or Issue | Outcome |
| Complaint | Taxpayer approached FTO | Notices, order sheets and assessment documents | Filed |
| FTO order | Order issued on February 19, 2026 | Right to obtain relevant record | Taxpayer favoured |
| Direction | Tax authorities told to provide documents | Assessment record copies | 15-day timeline |
| FBR challenge | Representation filed before President | FTO order contested | Rejected |
| Final effect | FTO order maintained | Requested tax records | To be furnished |
What the Decision Means for Taxpayers
The FBR challenged the FTO’s decision through a representation before the President. However, the President rejected the representation after finding no defect in the FTO’s decision. This means the original order requiring the FBR to provide the taxpayer with the requested tax records remains operative.
Tax lawyer Waheed Shahzad Butt, who represented the taxpayer, welcomed the decision and said it strengthened transparency and accountability in tax proceedings. He argued that taxpayers must have access to records concerning their own cases so they can defend themselves effectively.
| Compliance Signal: The decision should encourage FBR field formations to comply with similar FTO directions without unnecessary delay, especially where taxpayers seek basic records from their own cases. |
Transparency Pressure on Tax Administration
The case highlights a wider concern in tax administration: when taxpayers do not receive copies of notices, order sheets and assessment papers, they may be left unsure about the basis of proceedings against them. That can weaken confidence in the system and make disputes more difficult to resolve.
With the representation dismissed, the taxpayer’s requested records are required to be furnished in line with the FTO’s order. The decision may also be cited in similar disputes where taxpayers seek access to their own assessment record and tax offices delay or refuse disclosure.
| Practical Note: Applicants and taxpayers should still follow the proper legal process for requesting records and keep written proof of applications, reminders and official responses. |
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is based on available public reporting and provided case details. It should not be treated as legal or tax advice.

